Dragonsinger Book Review: Harpers, Hogwarts and a Hawaiian Kolohe

Dragonsinger Book Review: Harpers, Hogwarts and a Hawaiian Kolohe

posted in: Book Reviews, Writing | 0 | This post may contain referral links. See privacy policy for more.

Earlier this month, I reviewed Dragonsong by Anne McCaffrey. Today, I will be reviewing the second book in the Harper Hall of Pern trilogy, Dragonsinger. If you wish to read the first book, I highly recommend you stop and read the first review, as this second review may spoil a key surprise.

In my last review, I drew comparisons between Dragonsong and the Giver Quartet. Dragonsinger then is most comparable to Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, but McCaffrey’s book is more upbeat (i.e., light hearted and less serious).


There are quite a few parallels between Harry Potter and Dragonsinger.

We join Menolly arriving on dragonback to the Harper Hall. This is the place of which she has dreamed of likely since Petiron began teaching her about music back at Half Circle Sea Hold. The Harper Hall is not at all what she had imagined it would be like, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. She is there to learn music and throughout the book, there are many teachers who invest a great deal in her education (much like Harry Potter’s education at Hogwarts).

Dragonsinger Book Review

I listened to this book, just like Dragonsong, through the OneClickDigital subscription through my local library. Sally Darling narrates again and once more, she does a lovely job!

Master Robinton has a twinkle in his eye similar to that of Albus Dumbledore, and like Dumbledore, he tracks the movements of his star pupil, Menolly, while keeping busy, managing any business that crops up throughout the continent of Pern. He is a very busy man, but remains compassionate, thoughtful, and generous. The best kind of leader.


The difference between Dragonsong and Dragonsinger is night and day, quite literally. Dragonsong is filled with a sad darkness and a sense of emotional and physical isolation. The ways of Half Circle Sea Hold are quite insular, given its closed off location, but also the mentality of Menolly’s father who happens to be the leader of the community. Menolly’s family attempts to snuff out her musical gifts at ever opportunity causing Menolly to feel she has no choice but to run away, at great personal peril.

Dragonsinger, on the other hand is full of light, laughter and friendship. Menolly’s gifts are revered and celebrated, even if a few Harpers are skeptical at first. They attend a Gather, pretty much a festival with lots of food, drink, entertainment, and trade/shopping! Life flows freely and abundantly in the Harper Hall – quite a 180 from Half Circle Sea Hold. There are still challenges to overcome, but none as serious as those she faced in the first book. Dragonsinger is a comparative breath of fresh air to Dragonsong.

The best part of reading Dragonsinger was the characters. Menolly’s fire-lizards continue to play a big part in the story, especially with regard to Menolly’s emotional growth. Each Master Harper has something unique to offer, as well as the Journeyman Harpers. We meet Piemur, a young rascal with an angelic soprano voice. Al and I spent a few years during our childhood in Hawaii, and there is a Hawaiian word that captures Piemur’s mischievious spirit: Kolohe (pronounced ko-lo-hay). Basically it means “endearing troublemaker” and that’s Piemur to a T.

I have begun reading Dragondrums and Piemur is the main character. I was surprised that Menolly was not the main character in this book since she was in the first two of the trilogy. That being said, I am on Chapter 5 and it really isn’t an issue. Piemur is a very pleasant character to spend time with. Stay tuned for my review of Dragondrums!

You can read a full summary of Dragonsinger at the Pern Wikia page here.

Mac
Follow Us

Mac

The younger of the Z.Y. Doyle sisters, Mac's favorite show growing up was Inspector Gadget. As a child, she would often pretend her Baby-G watch was a radio connection to the FBI. As an adult, Mac has maintained her super nerd status, applying it daily in her writing, graphic designs, and sticker designs.
Mac
Follow Us
Share this!
Comments are closed.